top of page
Search

Understanding the Manosphere

Lenore Lambert
2 days ago
6 min read

Updated: 14 hours ago

Silhouette of a man standing against a white background

In an interview with an international crisis negotiator, the question was asked: How do you remain professional and solution oriented with people who've done atrocious things - murder, theft, oppression of other humans? That is, how could he be level-headed and constructive with people who'd done patently unacceptable, horrifying things?


His answer: you need to be able to recognise the capacity within yourself to behave the same way.


I was presented with this in a university lecture over thirty years ago and it was so striking that it stayed with me. I remember recoiling from it. How could you possibly not judge such people who cause so much suffering, engage in so much violence, who represent everything that's wrong in the world? How could you move towards them rather than away from them? How could you WANT to understand them?


I couldn't get past my judgment and I found it astonishing that anyone could. Yet what this impressively skilled and experienced person had learnt was that unless you do, you will not be able to influence them.


Fast forward many decades, and I found myself on a flight to the USA, curiously enquiring why the flight attendant I was chatting with thought that Donald Trump was "the only one who can save America" (which inspired this blog post about the need for certainty turning toxic.) Back in the day I would have judged her a moron and gone back to my seat.


These days, I allow my curiosity to draw me in at least close enough for some semblance of understanding. The arrival of judgment can in fact be a little flag inviting us to grow.


I also like road-testing my model of the Nine Elements of Human Flourishing to see if it's robust enough to explain their behaviour. It hasn't yet failed.


The same motives recently lured me to watch the so-called documentary by Louis Theroux called Inside the Manosphere (currently on Netflix). Theroux interviews and observes a number of these man-fluencers and their acolytes. And while it barely qualifies as a documentary in the true sense, it gives a peek into this world and what drives its protagonists and followers.


Like the international terrorists, my first impulse when exposed to these people was aversion. Their views and behaviour are repugnant - so incredibly harmful. But I amped up my curiosity and watched to the end.


The Nine Elements of Human Flourishing
The Nine Elements of Human Flourishing

Here are the insights I gleaned:


  1. These are men who, like all of us, are yearning to flourish but they are terribly misguided about how to do it. They've overdone some Elements of Human Flourishing which turns them toxic.

  2. This deluded-ness is due to their human needs being starved - in large part to either the absence of a father in their developmental years, or the presence of a toxic one who role modeled misogyny, judgment, coercive power and aggression, leaving the young boys with a sense of non-acceptance, powerlessness and inadequacy.

  3. As a result these boys have grown into men with a dire sense of lack regarding one or more of the Elements of: Belonging, Connection, Autonomy, Certainty and Material Security (and probably more).

  4. In order to nourish these Elements, they have overdone them so badly that they have turned toxic. For example, in order to belong to the brotherhood (Belonging), they felt they had to be a real man, which in their world was like their father or other role models whose stereotypical masculinity was super-charged. In order to nourish the Element of Autonomy, they've followed these role models into the belief that power over others is what we need to feel our autonomy. In order to nourish the Element of Material Security, they indulge in whatever behaviour or attitude yields money (their social media followers can pay them to do things or say things to people).

  5. This mode of being brings followers, likes, and cash, all of which are clear indicators of approval from people, providing at least some indication that they are a success (which is important to feeling like a man and gives a hit of something adjacent to Connection and Belonging).


Now just scan back over the bits I underlined in that list. Are you familiar with any of them? I know that territory for sure! This is how I can understand my capacity to behave like them, to feel something like the way they do, as the crisis negotiator advised.


When you believe that the only alternative to these views is to be scorned, invisible, powerless, and adrift, of course, you're going to choose this path. If you have no mental models for understanding the human experience (like the Nine Elements), all you know is you're hurting and you want a way out.


The most compelling scene in this documentary was a moment when Theroux asked one of the manfluencers: do you ever consider just being a nice person?


It's the only thing that seemed to give the guy pause. The question seemed to stop him in his tracks. He thought for a moment and then said essentially: that wouldn't earn me any money.


I've written before (and given a TEDx talk) about the measly relationship between money and happiness. Not one of these manfluencers seemed happy. The closest they came was self-satisfied, maybe a bit proud (in the egoic sense, not in the appreciation sense), but there was definitely not joy. In fact tension was what radiated from these people.


At the heart of it, these manfluencers are desperately seeking Belonging, Connection and Material Security but going about it in all the wrong ways. They've achieved plenty of Material Security through their followers shelling out cash to belong to their sphere, but haven't noticed that this isn't making them happy. Their following is possibly the closest thing they’ve experienced to belonging, but it's a very poor and precarious substitute.


In one of the saddest moments, they interviewed two young men who were followers and avid admirers. One of them was a young Mexican man desperate to help his family out of poverty. He seemed to have few prospects of being a success in conventional terms.


His manfluencer-of-choice preaches that anything is possible, that you don't have to accept your lot in life or what the system dictates; that any man can pull himself up by the bootstraps and be a success like said manfluencer.


The appeal of this promised road to Material Security is obvious to the young man in such a powerless position. I wonder, if my future was so bleak, if I could see no mainstream options to lift myself and my family out of poverty, would I respond the same way to someone telling me I can make it?


Would I be willing to adopt delusional and harsh views of others (in this case it's women but you could substitute any group in here) if I believed that was my only ticket to a better life? Can I really be confident that I wouldn't? I don't know that I can.


To deal with this phenomenon, neither pure judgment, nor pure compassion will cut it. We need toughness and kindness – or, in psychologist Kristin Neff's terms, both tender and fierce compassion. In her model, tender compassion accepts and soothes, while fierce compassion protects, provides and motivates. We need to bring our capacity for strength to bear in stopping these people from causing harm where we can (it's appropriate that the Tate brothers are behind bars for example) AND we also need to help young men sidestep the abyss of unworthiness and lostness that besets them.


The problem of toxic masculinity is not one I personally can help solve in any meaningful way. I don't know any people with these attitudes. However, personal growth is a practice, so every time we find ourselves recoiling from another, judging another, or even wishing harm, it's an opportunity to practice flexing the muscles we want to grow (or sending electricity down the neural pathways we want to reinforce). For me, opening my mind to understand the manosphere is a great opportunity to practice holding those two seemingly contradictory characteristics simultaneously: toughness and kindness, protectiveness and compassion at the same time.


It made me wonder: where are the men offering more beneficial alternatives? If it was a choice between a toxic man telling him there's a way to be a success and well balanced man offering a different, more constructive and wise path, maybe he'd take the latter. (I do think in these cases it has to be a man.) This podcast by David Brooks from the Atlantic takes a wonderful walk through the different visions of masculinity over time, and shows how the toxic variety really is just one (extreme) version of many.


Here in Australia there are programs emerging that are helping boys to more healthy ideas about masculinity and mental health. This is encouraging.


I wish I could share with them The Nine Elements of Human Flourishing as a roadmap out of their quagmire of lostness and fear. However they'd need to hear it from a man whose membership in the brotherhood is indisputable because they are so patently desperate to belong.


Perhaps we could convince Arnold Schwarzenegger to start a new career as a spiritual guide.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page